GreyGhostGames

Attributes or No Attributes?

Attributes or No Attributes?

I know this is an ancient debate in the Fudge community, but I'm just returning after 15 years of playing other games. I'm building a rules-lite fantasy game for my group, in large part because we play over the Internet, and as few mechanics as possible seems desirable.

I'm just struggling a bit over attributes. My extinct is to eliminate them in favor of skills, gifts and faults, except for Damage Capacity, since that's a mechanic I think doesn't add a lot of overhead. My players by and large have always played attribute-based systems, so they may be skeptical.

What's the general view on attributes, and if anyone has dropped them, how has that worked?

Administrator has disabled public posting. Please login or register in order to proceed.

Re: Attributes or No Attributes?

The only problem I've encountered with that approach is when players don't pick a representative skill to stand in for a particular attribute. For example, if you don't have a skill involving strength or some aspect of physical prowess then you need to decide how to deal with a situation where raw strength is needed.

I've used "phantom" attributes to cover this: the players need at least one skill relating to each of Physical, Mental and Spiritual, for instance; other than that they take whatever skills they wish. It avoids having a fundamental gap at the heart of the character.

‘If a man does not make new acquaintance as he advances through life, he will soon find himself left alone.
A man, Sir, should keep his friendship in constant repair.’

- Samuel Johnson

BigJackBrass
Two Separate Gorillas
useravatar
Offline
103 Posts
Website 
Administrator has disabled public posting. Please login or register in order to proceed.

Re: Attributes or No Attributes?

OVA:The Anime Role-Playing Game is a rules light rpg without attributes. The way they did it was to just assume you're average unless you take skills/gifts/faults/whathaveyou that modify it. So, if you're playing as a 17-year old high school student, the base assumption is that you're middle of the road (C grades, not athletic but not unathletic, etc). If you want them to be strong, add that. If you want them clutzy, add that. Basically, you don't have to cover the mundane, middle-of-the-road stuff, just the things that make the character different.

Administrator has disabled public posting. Please login or register in order to proceed.

Re: Attributes or No Attributes?

I've run Fudge in both forms before, and will probably continue to use both. That said, I have found three major uses for attributes.

1) The default at Fair instead of Poor makes them useful for nonspecialized traits, as opposed to specialized professional skills and the like.

2) Them being more expensive to advance than skills makes them useful for anything that would be disproportionately useful as a skill.

3) They're a short list, which can make them really useful at briefly mechanically communicating setting or theme for a particular game.

The [-] die.

Administrator has disabled public posting. Please login or register in order to proceed.

Re: Attributes or No Attributes?

Fate uses a short list of skills and bakes the attributes into skills (https://fate-srd.com/fate-core/default-skill-list). It works fine. If someone doesn't have an aporopriate skill you default.  If it becomes an issue you could look at the defaulting skill web from Shadowrun (1st and 2nd edition).

Administrator has disabled public posting. Please login or register in order to proceed.

Re: Attributes or No Attributes?

In my Fudge/Fate hybrid, I use the D&D attributes.  Yep, the familiar six.  Then PC's have five "aspects" like in Fate or the roles in EZFudge.  The aspects define how they use the 6 attributes.

Also, if they want to use an attribute in a way that is close somewhat related to an aspect, they roll at one level lower.  So an engineer knows some science, but not as much as a scientist (and vice-versa) so they roll on INTELLIGENCE but one rung lower on the ladder.  If it is a real stretch, they roll two rungs lower.

Don't know if this helps, but it's what I do.

Administrator has disabled public posting. Please login or register in order to proceed.
There are 0 guests and 0 other users also viewing this topic

Board Info

Board Stats
 
Total Topics:
294
Total Polls:
0
Total Posts:
1276
User Info
 
Total Users:
2394
Newest User:
erikawritesbooks
Members Online:
0
Guests Online:
272

Latest Posts

I don't check for new Fudge products more...
Is it possible to have the scale roller on the...
I'm glad it's useful

Dice Roller

 
 
 
 
Settings...
Color: 
Number: 
Done

Member Login